Thanksgiving ‘25 preorders are now closed.
We are no longer accepting new Thanksgiving orders by phone or email. Walk-ins / in-person only please.
We have limited availability on many items for walk-ins, on a first-come, first-served basis only. These cannot be reserved in advance or over the phone. Please visit the store in person or TEXT US with questions at (718) 569-8426.
Check out our Thanksgiving FAQ for useful tips and cooking suggestions.
Available Items for Walk-Ins
We’ll be updating this page regularly with current inventory on Thanksgiving-friendly options from our butcher counter. This is the absolute fastest and best way to find out what we have available.
Place A Sandwich Order Online
Follow the link below to place a sandwich order for pickup or delivery. Our kitchen is open 7 days a week, from 9am to 4pm.
Order A Gift Card
A Foster Sundry gift card would make anybody’s day. We offer a variety of denominations, and they can be used on anything in the shop… from breakfast burritos to ribeye steaks.